JOHN BUCHAN (1875-1940)

Plakos island in the Aegean sea was the home of the Arabin family.  The Arabins, Greek owners in fee simple of most of the island, owned a manorial estate, several small villages, and ruled over a population of farmers and fisherfolk that numbered in the thousands.  Kore Arabin was the only daughter of Shelley Arabin, “the worst man i’ve ever known” according one of his contemporaries.  He was an associate of Percy Shelley and Lord Byron but was unpopular due to his rake-hellish practices, involving ancient Grecian rites and various sorts of dubious sacrificial sacraments.

Vernon Milburne was the scion of generations of evangelical cotton processing magnates, the noble residents of Severns Hall.  Vernon’s parents died while he was still young, leaving him sole inheritor of vast estates and lots of money.  Vernon suffered from a peculiar nightmare from an early age.  The dream only occurred on April 1st, so there was one per year:  asleep in his bedroom, he would suddenly awake and see a door where no door had been in reality.  Through the door was another room and another door and another room:  a chain of apartments, twenty in number, that decreased one by one as the years passed.  The last room would be reached when Vernon was 27 years of age.  He was somehow pre-selected by some mysterious power to participate in an island adventure taking place in the future in which he is pre-destined to meet his future bride at the moment of his final nightmarish vision.

Edward Leithen, the narrator, met Vernon through an introduction by his nephew Charles;  the three men were present at an anniversary ball and became friendly.  Later in the same year, while hiking in the Westmoreland Hills, Edward sprains an ankle and hobbles to nearby Severns Hall and gets to know Vernon well.  They share histories and later both serve in the first World War, are wounded, but survive.

Early in the post-war period, the two men re-engage with the London social scene and come to be acquainted with Kore, who is in England to be educated and socialized.  She is an outspoken and occasionally rude young lady who thoughtlessly antagonizes many of her friends by telling the truth about their foibles and habitual behaviors.  However, Vernon is entranced, and so is Edward to a certain extent.  After five years of off and on association between the three, Kore returns to Plakos because she is running short of money.  She arrives and is confronted with hostile peasants who see her as the cause of various miseries such as declining fish stocks and poor harvests, mainly because she is the local authority and as such is held responsible for the general welfare.  Also she seems to hold a sort of spiritual responsibility for the people’s well-being.

Vernon happens to be in the area, sailing around the Aegean in a small yacht, and hears about Kore’s troubles during a stopover in Athens.  He hires a few henchmen and sails to the rescue.  Edward Leithen is also nearby and stops in for a visit.

The natives are restless, partly because Spring has just arrived and partly because they are anxious and apprehensive about ancient mysteries centered on the Grecian harvest and generative gods, Demeter, Pan, the Irinyes, Persephone, and others.  The local priest seems powerless to influence them, and the villagers become more and more possessed by ancient archetypes, to the point that they decide to sacrifice Kore to appease the gods.

The Dancing Floor is a flat valley located over a ridge from the town (Kynaetha by name) and is the site of age-old rites of renewal and sacrifice.  The idea being that a King is appointed along with a virgin and a prince to represent the ceremonial avatars. A foot race around the Floor is held to determine who is King;  the other two are selected by popular acclaim.  Vernon, having infiltrated the peasant ranks, wins the foot race and is elected King.  Kore, the subject of popular resentment, is naturally selected as virgin, and Marius, a friend of Vernon, is honored by becoming the Prince.

There’s an uprising,  the peasants obtain rifles and organize themselves into groups in order to surround the mansion (with Kore inside) and deal with outsiders. Vernon, Leithen, and a few helpers creep around boulders and scale sea-cliffs in their attempts to rescue Kore.  After numerous futile attempts to elude the ubiquitous villagers, Leithen manages to get into the house.  He convinces Kore of the imminent dangers threatening her and they combine resources for the best defense they can manage.

Meanwhile, Vernon and Marius, under cover of night, succeed in sneaking into the besieged mansion.  Shortly after, Kore convinces Leithen that the only recourse available to them is for herself and Marius to participate in the ritual.  So they dress up, and walk down through the brilliant moonlight to the Dancing Floor.

The peasantry is overwhelmed by the beauty of the pair and spontaneously throw up their hands and bow to Kore and Marius and go back home.  If this seems a bit peculiar and anti-climactic, it might have seemed that way to Buchan also…  At any rate, he couldn’t think of any better ending, apparently, so the reader has to settle for Vernon and Kore falling in love and Edward Leithen cruising off into the sunset looking for consolation and further adventures.

This was a disappointing book in some ways.  It was a bit like one of those signposts with fingerboards all pointing in different directions.  Somewhat disjointed and vague.  I’ve read quite a bit of Buchan’s work and this was not one of his best;  compared to the Richard Hannay series, or the novels devoted to Edward Leithen himself, it appears weak.  On the other hand, Buchan is such a powerful describer of landscapes and weather, that it’s a thrill to experience walking in his world.  He’s a master of ambiance, able to drench his prose in auras from Imperial England, or from adventures and excursions into the earth’s remote areas:  northern Canada, unknown Asia, or even unpopulated Scotland.  Reading this book, i was reminded of other works i’ve read that were saturated with the ancient Greek mythos:  “The Great God Pan” by Arthur Machen, and one of E.M. Forster’s short stories, which i can’t remember the name of.  And others;  “Pan” by Knut Hamsen which i haven’t yet read…  for further study i’d recommend Robert Graves’ The White Goddess” in which he discusses early Greek matrilineal society and accounts for many of the seminal Greek myths.


15 thoughts on “THE DANCING FLOOR”

  1. I’m glad you mentioned Buchan’s ability to describe atmospheres and physical environments. I think he was good at that, Mudpuddle. Sounds like the book’s at least got that going for it.


  2. Superb commentary. Too bad the plot was muddled. I be OK might be OK with this as I can overlook plot issues if there are other compensating factors. I love well written discriptions. I also love references to mythology.,


  3. ‘Tis always a treat to read your postings. I so much enjoy being surprised by different authors, new titles, and your nicely written synopses and critiques. In this case, I’ll be content with having read The 39 Steps.


    1. ha; i wondered if someone would mention that book and you did! if you haven’t tried the Hannay series, i’d recommend it… Greenmantle, The Three Hostages, and Mr. Standfast are the main ones…


  4. I tried to read 39 Steps but had a hard time getting into it. Just wasn’t the time, I guess. I did see a hilarious local production of it at the University I work at. They have an excellent drama department. A young man, a vocal major, that I played for stepped in at the last minute to replace someone (also someone I played for) who had some kind of emotional breakdown. He learned all his parts inside one week and was superb and I told him so.


    1. i’m astonished by the way some people can memorize lines and songs like that… and poetry… it’s some sort of genetic gift, i assume… i had a sister-in-law long ago who could do that: she could hear something once and remember it forever… totally amazing…


  5. “spontaneously throw up their hands and bow” I got a good giggle from your description of the ending. 😀 I guess I’ll pass on this one. Still need to read 39 Steps, though!

    Thanks for pointing me to The White Goddess, by the way…I read Haggard’s novel “She” earlier this year and found the concept fascinating, though the story itself not a favorite. Maybe Graves’s book would help me understand the origin of that mythos, or at least its continuous appeal.


    1. it’s a fascinating book, but not a particularly easy read… and there’s some controversy re Graves’ interpretations of Greek mythology… but given that, he’s a dynamically interesting writer…


  6. This both sounds and does not sound like a Buchan book. I have read many and enjoyed them; but this one seems, I do not know…..weird! I will pass this one! Speaking of Graves, I was always kind of wary of him, but I started reading I Claudius and I am blown away!


    1. Graves was definitely not a middle-of-the-road intellect… but slanted as he was, he was so brilliant that he’s well worth reading, imo… his autobiography is excellent and informative: Goodby to All That… hope the heat isn’t too awful down there; tx for the comment…

      Liked by 1 person

  7. I’ve just finished reading Buchan’s Sick Heart River & that’s quite different to most of the others I’ve read. It’s very philosophical but it was his last novel & I’m pretty sure he knew he was dying…I think Mr Standfast is my favourite. I’ve been rereading a lot of his books that I read years ago but I haven’t read The Dancing Floor before.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s